Badger cull is ‘barbaric and ineffective’

Trish Marchant says: The Government plans for a culling policy, which will grant farmers licenses to arrange for the shooting of badgers on their land, is not the answer to bovine TB and comes just a week after former Government adviser Lord Krebs publicly rejected badger culling as an ‘ineffective’ method of addressing bovine TB.

Caroline Lucas, Green MP, is an honorary vice president of the RSPCA and a longtime campaigner on animal protection issues, and has said:

“The decision by Defra to give the go-ahead for a barbaric slaughter of badgers in our countryside shows a shocking disregard for animal welfare – and flies in the face of scientific evidence on the spread of bovine TB. The belief that badger culling represents an effective solution has already been disproven.”

After a nine year randomised cull trial which cost the UK taxpayer £50m and destroyed 10,000 badgers, the Independent Scientific Group on Cattle TB concluded that ‘badger culling can make no meaningful contribution to cattle TB control in Britain.

“Even the Government adviser responsible for a 10-year experimental cull in the 1990s, Lord Krebs, has now rejected the method. Perhaps it is this lack of evidence to support the policy that has made Defra so reluctant to publish the results of its consultation.”

Caroline continued: “Eighty per cent of bovine TB transmission is thought to be caused by cattle-to-cattle infection. Given that it is a respiratory disease, this high rate can be attributed to the trend towards intensive dairy farming, in which cattle are kept in crowded conditions. Rather than cruel and ineffective mass culling, restrictions on cattle movement and contact between badgers and cattle should be given high priority, in addition to greater efforts to introduce a vaccination programme.”


3 Comments to “Badger cull is ‘barbaric and ineffective’”

  1. According to an Independent article, “Evidence of overwhelming public opposition to the proposed cull of badgers was withheld until the Government had decided to go ahead with the controversial plan.”

    David M. Davison

  2. The Humane Society International UK reports on an open letter to DEFRA Minister Caroline Spelman calling on the government to postpone the proposed slaughter of English badgers:

    David M. Davison

  3. To put your name to a petition created by Brain May, please visit:

    David M. Davison

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s